Follow me:

Why All Christian Theology is Analogical: Navigating Human Language and the Infinite Nature of God

Play episode

One of the unique challenges in Christian theology is the task of speaking about God—a Being who is eternal, infinite, and transcendent—through human language, which is finite, limited, and bound by created experience. This gap between the nature of God and the nature of our language brings us to an important principle in theology: all Christian theological language is analogical.

What Does It Mean for Theology to Be Analogical?

In theological terms, “analogical” language is a way of speaking that uses analogy to bridge the vast gap between God’s divine essence and human understanding. The analogy assumes a resemblance or correspondence between the divine reality and our human concepts, without claiming an exact equivalence. This approach holds that, while our descriptions of God reflect certain truths about Him, they can never fully capture His essence.

Take, for example, when the Bible describes God as a “rock” (Psalm 18:2). We don’t believe God is literally a rock but understand that God’s steadfastness, reliability, and strength can be likened to a rock. This analogical language, while imperfect, is a necessary tool for humans to relate to and understand the divine.

The Finite Nature of Human Language

Human language is shaped by created reality—our world, relationships, experiences, and history. Words and concepts we use every day, such as “love,” “justice,” and “truth,” carry meaning for us because they’re rooted in our human experience. Yet, when we attempt to describe God, we are trying to apply these created categories to an uncreated, infinite Being. Our language can point toward God’s attributes and actions but ultimately falls short of fully capturing who God is in Himself.

In Christian theology, this gap is acknowledged but bridged by analogy. Just as a painter might use different shades and strokes to capture light and shadow, theologians use analogical language to hint at God’s qualities, always mindful that their words remain approximations rather than definitive statements.

The Challenge of God’s Transcendence and Immanence

A fundamental Christian belief is that God is both transcendent (above and beyond creation) and immanent (present within creation). God’s transcendence implies that His being and ways are so far above human comprehension that our language and concepts alone are inadequate. This is why in Exodus 3:14, God reveals Himself to Moses simply as “I AM WHO I AM.” This phrase conveys God’s self-existence and independence from anything we might otherwise compare Him to.

Yet God’s immanence means that He reveals Himself within creation and desires to be known by His people. This tension between transcendence and immanence is one reason why theology relies on analogy. For example, calling God a “Father” draws on the analogy of human fatherhood—something accessible and relatable to us—while also acknowledging that God’s fatherhood surpasses all earthly expressions of the term.

Analogical Language in Christian Doctrine

In Christian theology, analogical language shows up in every area of doctrine. Here are a few examples:

1. God as Creator: We use terms like “creation” and “maker” to describe God’s role in bringing the universe into existence. While we understand “making” or “creating” in terms of human creativity, God’s act of creation was entirely unique—He created everything ex nihilo (out of nothing), a concept beyond our full comprehension.

2. The Trinity: When Christians speak of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, they use terms like “person” and “relationship.” Yet, the inner life of the Trinity is unlike any relationship humans experience. The language helps us approach the mystery but doesn’t completely unravel it.

3. God’s Attributes: Attributes such as God’s “love” and “justice” are based on our experiences of these concepts but far exceed our human understanding. God’s love, for example, is steadfast, boundless, and sacrificial, in ways that the term “love” only begins to describe.

4. The Incarnation: In Jesus Christ, God “became flesh and dwelt among us” (John 1:14). The doctrine of the Incarnation bridges the gap between human and divine, as God entered into human experience while remaining fully God. Yet, the mystery of how Jesus is both fully God and fully human is one that our analogies only partially express.

Analogical Language as a Humble Approach to Theology

Theologians throughout history, such as Augustine, Thomas Aquinas, and Karl Barth, have acknowledged that theological language must be humble. Aquinas, for example, argued that we know God per analogiam, or “by way of analogy.” He saw analogical language as both a way of affirming truth about God and a way of respecting His transcendence.

This analogical approach also guards us from theological arrogance. By acknowledging that our language about God is always analogical, we admit that we’re dealing with partial truths, not the entirety of God. This prevents us from assuming that we have an exhaustive grasp of divine mysteries, encouraging instead a posture of humility, reverence, and wonder.

The Role of Revelation

While theology is analogical, Christians believe that God has truly revealed Himself. Through Scripture, we find images, metaphors, and teachings that reveal who God is in ways humans can grasp. Jesus Christ, the “Word made flesh,” represents the ultimate revelation of God in a way humans can understand, but even here, our understanding is limited and requires faith.

As Paul says in 1 Corinthians 13:12, “For now we see through a glass, darkly; but then face to face.” Our language about God may be dim and incomplete, yet it points to a deeper reality we will fully experience in the age to come.

Embracing the Mystery

Analogical language in theology allows us to speak of God in a meaningful way while recognizing the vastness of the mystery that remains. By using analogy, we can affirm God’s attributes and character in ways that draw us into relationship with Him, while also acknowledging the limits of our comprehension.

In Christian worship, theology, and prayer, we find joy in the mystery, knowing that our analogies, though limited, reflect a God who is infinitely beyond our grasp yet intimately present in our lives. And in that mystery, we find both humility and hope, trusting that one day, as the Apostle John assures us, “we shall see Him as He is” (1 John 3:2).

More from this show

SEMINARY UNBOXED

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.